Shop Mobile More Submit  Join Login
  • Art Print
  • Canvas
  • Photo
Download JPG 2206 × 1552


Submitted on
April 5, 2012
Image Size
3.1 MB


26,776 (9 today)
148 (who?)
What is this Germany you speak of? by 1Blomma What is this Germany you speak of? by 1Blomma
“At the end of the 2nd World War, many plans existed on how to deal with the German question. Some argued Europe without Germany could not sustain itself economically and should be de-Nazified and rehabilitated. Others, fuelled by revenge for the damage caused by her, argued for the total extermination of the German state and people. The final plan was more like the latter than the former. “The warmongering German people” should pay for their crimes with territorial concessions to their neighbours, forced sterilisation of all adults deemed to be Nazis, and naturalisation of the remainder. To lower the population even further, Germans were denied food rations that were instead being sent to the remaining European population. It is estimated that between 15.000.000 and 20.000.000 Germans starved in the first five years after the end of the war.
Politically, Germany ceased to exist as a state in 1946, when it was divided between its neighbouring countries. Schleswig-Holstein, with the addition of Hamburg and the island of Rügen, became Danish. Prussia was incorporated as a republic in the Soviet Union. Mecklenburg, Pomerania, Brandenburg, Saxony, Thuringia, Danzig and the eastern, Polish populated part of Silesia was added to Poland. Czechia was extended with Bavaria to the west and Silesia to the north while Slovakia was made independent. Belgium annexed the Central Rhineland, and the Netherlands annexed Hanover and the Ruhr area. The remainder was annexed by France.
The controversial plan for the total annihilation of the German State and People was at the time seen as a necessity. However, historians today are beginning to look at it as the single greatest mistake of the 20th century. Some even go as far as to say that “Europe without a prosperous Germany is like America would be without the entire Midwest.” These theories are often looked down upon by stating that in less than 20 years, the GDP levels of Central Europe are already beginning to reach their pre-war level.
Supporters of the decision state that “an important factor that has to be taken into consideration is that humanity is saved from a potential Third World War, since there is no Germany to worry about”. – “A Brief History of the German People;” Adam S. Thompson: 1963

Life in all of these zones was harsh, in some zones possibly even harsher than it had been during the actual war. In the Polish and French zones the death rates were highest and most anyone could be put in jail, killed, or sterilised for even minor actions. Witnesses report that public executions occurred in both the French and Polish zones, though these claims are quite dubious. The death rates and living conditions nonetheless led to the German Exodus of 1948. About 10.000.000(of which only three quarters survived) migrated to Austria due to the “lenient” policies adopted by the American occupational authority there. The population of Austria is as of today more than twice as large as it was in 1945.
The inhabitants in the Dutch and Danish zones were quite lucky compared to this. A scheme was designed by the Danish government to determine which subjects to forcibly sterilise and which to neutralise (a similar scheme was adopted by the Dutch some time later). Could the person in question prove that they either actively opposed the Nazi government during the years 1933-1945, spoke another language than German as their first language or even had relatives living in Denmark (for the Dutch in the Netherlands) they escaped sterilisation.

The task of repopulating former Germany was solved differently by each nation. Poland, having lost a sizeable portion of its eastern territories to the Soviet Union resettled refugees from the East in the West. The first few years in the French zone looked quite dark, but when African nationalism rose in the mid-50s, the Pied-Noirs (French nationals living in Africa, primarily Algeria) were urged by DeGaulle to come home to the continent. Should they choose to settle in Swabia, Hesse, Franconia or the Palatinate they were given large benefits as opposed to “Old France”. The Belgian government chose to let most Germans stay, eventually creating a trilingual nation (French, Dutch and Saxon*). Denmark and the Netherlands, as stated above, naturalised large parts of the German population while sterilising and deporting only a few. Czechia could only be described as a mix of the other nations’ policies. In Prussia, the Old Prussian language was resurrected (together with lots of Lithuanian and Russian influence) and imposed on all Germans.

*Saxon is the Belgian version of German. It shares great similarities with Low German and Luxembourgish, with some French loanwords. It was imposed on everyone who did not wish to convert to Dutch or French.

Finished on April 5th, 2012
Add a Comment:
bruiser128 Featured By Owner Edited Nov 29, 2014
Never did like FDR's post WW2 plan, since they where CLEARLY
meant in the long run to make the USA dominant in the world.

Oh and the ones who said and believed that the total annihilation
of an ethnic group can go F@$% themselves to high heaven. 
ImperialKuatSystems Featured By Owner Oct 14, 2014  New member Student Traditional Artist
And why is Austria not divided between Italy, Hungary and Yugoslavia?
ImperialKuatSystems Featured By Owner Oct 14, 2014  New member Student Traditional Artist
Mazury and Slask should be polish, and Luzyce more integrated.
KunstIstLeben Featured By Owner Oct 9, 2014
This would have been heart breaking. I'd hate to live in a world where Rammstein and Subway to Sally didn't sing in German.
Sereniama Featured By Owner Jun 25, 2014  Hobbyist Writer
Should of gave Belgiu ma bit more.

Poland looks like eRepublik poland.
NomadicSky Featured By Owner May 14, 2014
Could this be done through assimilation and settlers from the countries that become part of? What happened to the German population? And do you by chance have one without Germany superimposed.
pj202718 Featured By Owner May 4, 2014
There's a map like this out there that has Austria and Switzerland "advised" to become Italian-speaking countries.
CheeseburgerTom Featured By Owner Feb 22, 2014
Interesting that Austria would avoid this fate.  You would think in the face of this savagery that regions near Switzerland would try to be annexed as new cantons before they could be annexed by France.
kris8171 Featured By Owner Dec 21, 2013
ahh yes, medevial (is that how you spell it?) eras germany, or the states that forms it today
Ghost-of-the-Past Featured By Owner Dec 21, 2013
Yeah for a murderous people that sounds like a really easy treatment - they got off the hook
Add a Comment: